What happens when a whiskey critic stops writing about great whiskey and starts making it? For Jay West, the answer is Provenance Bourbon and the journey in between is one worth hearing.
On this episode of Distillery Nation, I sat down with Jay West, the principal whiskey maker behind 1787 Provenance Bourbon and Reverie's, both produced through Middleburg Barrel Company in Virginia. Jay's path to production is anything but conventional. He started writing about whiskey in 2015, not as a career move, but as a way to learn. Those notes, shared openly with the online community, slowly built something rare in any industry: trust.
Over time, that trust opened doors. Moderating communities, leading single barrel selections, collaborating on unique projects. Each step wasn't a calculated career pivot it was the natural result of showing up consistently and adding value without expecting anything in return.
What struck me most was Jay's take on being a non-distilling producer (NDP). Where many in the craft world see NDP as a shortcut, Jay frames it as a discipline one that demands sharp curation and blending skills over reliance on the romance of the still. His approach to tasting, early mornings, no spicy food, multiple sessions over several days, reflects just how seriously he takes that responsibility.
And when it came time to release Provenance Bourbon, Jay waited. The whiskey wasn't ready, so it didn't ship. That kind of patience is rare, and the market responded with exactly the reception he was hoping for.
Jay also shared his thoughts on where whiskey is headed higher proof expressions, a deeper focus on hospitality, and a consumer base that increasingly wants the story behind the bottle.
Whether you're a craft distiller, a whiskey enthusiast, or someone building a brand from scratch, Jay's journey from critic to creator is full of lessons worth taking seriously.
Listen to the interview on the web
LINKS AND RESOURCES MENTIONED IN THIS EPISODE
Books
- The Wrinkle in Time (Affiliate)
Thanks for Listening!
Thanks so much for joining me again this month. Have some feedback you’d like to share? Leave a note in the comment section below!
If you enjoyed this episode, please share it with your friends.
Also, please leave an honest review for The Distillery Nation Podcast on Apple Podcasts! Ratings and reviews are extremely helpful and greatly appreciated! They do matter in the rankings of the show, and I read each and every one of them.
